"Poorly executed and not terribly fun at all."

"Fun but I didn't make it through its original growing pains (read: the Blood clan taking over the world)"

Server: Darktide

"Some of my greatest online memories came from AC2 with my allegiance. A fun game and I was sad to see it go."

"Fun for a short time, but it grew repetitive."

"Like City of Heroes, only Villains! I gave it a run after having quit CoH well before CoV came out. Fun for a time, like the first, but it didn't capture me."

"This was a fun game for a while, but the RvR imbalances drove me away."

Server: Iseult

"Too much grouping. I like to solo."

"An interesting concept and possible escape from the strangeness that is Second Life, but it wasn't easy to have fun in this game."

"I was never able to get into it for some reason."

Characters:

Marakhan, Amarr Industrialist — Started pretty recently. Not playing a lot now because of Halo 3 and Team Fortress 2, but I plan on playing more in the future.

"One of the most fun online experiences ever. A wonderfully deep and involved world."

Server: Mithaniel Marr

"The game I worked on, therefore I had to love it. Any of my opinions here are invalid because it was my baby."

Server: Various

"Great fun for a while but I got pissed at the ascension (I think) quest to get to 20 because the nemesis was broken for rangers or mesmers or both (whatever I was)"

"Don't get me started about the biggest failure of expectations ever..."

"Not a bad game, but very Eastern flavored and I'm more of a Westerner. I did have a cute wyvern pet though. ;)"

"Too hardcore for me."

"I was in a great guild, but the repetitive boar and bear killing destroyed me."

"Ah, the old school. I didn't play this too much because I started playing The Realm, but it was actually pretty fun."

"Well, it's pirates. That's the important piece. Unfortunately, everyone I know is on the same server but is not a Pirate (like me), and I haven't had the balls to reroll."

Server: Rackham

"Totally awesome fun for a good while. Got bored of the repetition after a while and with imbalances."

Server: Konried

Guild: Pirate Ninjas

"Cute and fun but I got over it pretty quickly."

"Tons of fun... my first experience in the online space."

"Ever since Snow Crash I've been obsessed with the idea of a virtual world. When I heard about Second Life for the first time, I got pretty excited. I tried it, I didn't like it at all. I tried it again, and it was full of sex and furries and random"

"I was a nearly invincible force known only as Ishap of Iniquity. Give me a game I can exploit and I will, but so will everyone else, and that will often ruin the game."

Server: Dread

Guild: Iniquity

Characters:

Ishap, — Yep, that was me. The guy who could only be hit by 1-3 players on the server and who could switch to offensive mode and dish out 600 dmg per cast.

"Good graphics, decent gameplay, and the advancement didn't make my brain die. For some reason, though, I found that I couldn't get into the multi-character party thing as much as just one."

"I liked fishing and the other little games. It was a little too kid-focused for me."

"One of my favorite experiences of all time until it got "carebear" (read: I was no longer the only one having fun)"

Server: Various

Characters:

Derkesthai, — Atlantic and Chesapeake, primarily.

"The game by 38 Studios!"